Mystery Puzzle ($5)

Mystery Puzzle ($5)


  • $5.00

Log in to add this item to your wishlist

Product Description

For $5, we will send you a brand new or like new (packaging may vary) mystery puzzle at random! This is a good chance to receive a great deal and a welcome surprise for any cuber. Your mystery puzzle is guaranteed to have a higher retail value than $5.

Mystery Puzzle Guarantee: we want your purchase of your Mystery Puzzle to be fun and worthwhile! If the Mystery Puzzle you receive was on sale when you purchased it, we will issue you store credit equal to the difference between the price of the Mystery Puzzle and the sale price. For example, if you purchase a $5 Mystery Puzzle and receive an item that was on sale for $3 at the time of purchase, we will issue you a $2 in store credit. Please contact us for guarantee claims and be sure to save the Mystery Puzzle packaging. 

Packaging and accessory availability may vary. Please note all sales are final.

Interested in more Mystery Puzzles? Check out the other options:

$3 Mystery Puzzle

$10 Mystery Puzzle

$25 Mystery Puzzle

$35 Mystery Puzzle

Easy Returns!

Not completely satisfied with this product? We accept returns within 4 weeks (28 days) past the delivery date, for either store credit, or a full refund to the payment method — the choice is yours.

Click to see exclusions and more details on our returns policy

Our Promise to You

All of our products are guaranteed to be free of defects, or we will replace and reship at no cost to you. Please contact us within 4 weeks (28 days) past the delivery date to report any issues with items you have purchased.

Please note that some new cubes when being used for the first few times may experience what is termed a "pop". This is when one or more parts of a puzzle pop out without any damage actually being done to any of the pieces. This also occurs from time to time during normal usage. Pops are typically not considered a defect if the parts which come off can be reassembled by hand.

Fast & Free Shipping Available!

  • Free standard U.S. shipping (includes Hawaii, Alaska, and AFO/APO) (2-5 business days) is offered for orders with a subtotal of $45.00+. Free expedited shipping (1-3 business days) is offered at $75.00+.
  • All orders are shipped from our New York warehouse.
  • Orders are shipped the same business day they are placed, or the next business day. The cutoff for same day shipping is 3PM EST.
  • There is no processing/handling surcharge — all our shipping rates are at rock-bottom.
For our customers outside the U.S.:
  • We ship to all countries not sanctioned by the U.S. government.
  • We advise that you look into your country's customs laws before ordering.

Click to learn more about our shipping methods

Product Specifications
Manufacturer Other
Type Other
Added 2020-10-26
Gross Weight 200g

Customer Reviews

Based on 26 reviews
Jonathan G. (United States)
Got what I asked for .

I ordered 2 of these $5 mystery puzzles and asked for wca puzzles , I got wca puzzles worth more than I ordered . Overalls would buy again.

Chris (United States)
Great puzzles!

I ordered two of the $5 and one $10 mystery puzzle, and they were all great - my kids all loved what they got. Definitely great value an a fun surprise!

B.S. (United States)
$5 Mystery puzzle

I got two $5 mystery puzzles. One on them was a $7 4 by 4, Ans the other was a $7 pyraminx duo. i really like these cubes

CubeAssist (United States)

For my Mystery Puzzle I got a Unicorn Cube which sounds really really really dumb and it pretty much is really really really dumb. It would be like if you took a Pyraminx, made it so you could only turn the tips, and then made the whole thing cubic. my record is like a 3rd of a second so that means it is really easy. Not super happy with it so that is why I am giving it a 4 star instead of a 5. but I cannot be mad because it is a mystery puzzle so that means you get what you get!

Hey, thanks for leaving your review! If this helps for future purchases, we do allow some control over what you get with Mystery Puzzles. If you know you don't want a simple puzzle, you can make a request using the order comments. We also take comments like 'give me a WCA puzzle', or 'don't give me a 3x3, I have too many'. We can accommodate anything along those lines.

Hope this helps!
- Angela

Customer (United States)

I got some really good cubes

Susan P. (United States)
Order was placed for my grandson, I believe he’s happy with my purchases.

My comment on top line. Thank you. Susan Pelzek

Samantha S. (United States)

Was really happy with what I got it was worth more than what I paid.

John R. (United States)
Mystery puzzle

I got a puzzle that was about twice the value I payed! Although I already had a skewb, its still cool I can get a random puzzle if I have run out of ideas.

Sampson H. (United States)

Mystery Puzzle ($5)

Brian R. (United States)
Meilong 2x2m

I got a stickered meilong 2x2 m ($7). It was surprisingly good, and I will be using it as my main instead of the YJ MGC 2x2.